I live in the USA and I am concerned about the future. I created this blog to share my thoughts on the economy and anything else that might catch my attention.
This is the End and a New Beginning
-
I've been thinking about this for some time.
After 21 years of writing this blog almost daily, I've decided to stop
writing the daily updates on the blog.
...
Silver Deep Dive
-
Silver had a memorable year (+148%). Some of this can be explained by a
decline in the dollar. I decided to do some ML analysis to look for other
insights....
Here's a big story that didn't happen: the U.S. economy did not collapse dragging down the rest of the world.
The "big story" was postponed several years.
The escape from calamity had many causes, including optimistic American consumers and the Bush tax cuts. But none mattered more than the Federal Reserve's policy of cheap credit.
Cheap credit postponed our problems.
"We didn't lose the jobs in automobiles and housing that we usually lose in a recession", says economist Allan Meltzer of the Carnegie Melon University.
Job losses were postponed and magnified.
Housing did even better...
Housing problems were postponed and magnified.
It is six years later, almost to the day, and this is where we are now.
Relief over emergency measures to prop up the euro and prevent Greece's debt crisis spreading across Europe sent London's FTSE 100 soaring more than 5% today.
Here's a big story that didn't happen: the European economy did not collapse dragging down the rest of the world.
"It does not solve the fundamental fiscal problems but it gives countries now several years for swift action."
Debt is once again being used to postpone ongoing debt problems.
What really caught my eye was that despite the fact that we created almost 300,000 jobs, wages were basically flat and they’ve been flat almost since the beginning of the year. So, this excess capacity in the labor market is now showing through in wage disinflation. We’re really on the throws now for the first time in my professional life of actually seeing wage deflation. So that I think was the story beneath the veneer of the unemployment report today.
I offer an anecdotal evidence story.
Each year I need my sprinkler system tested for backflow. This is to ensure that my sprinkler doesn't feed water back into the water supply that we drink. It cost me $40 last year to have it done. I called up the guy I normally use and this is what he said. I paraphrase from memory.
I'm only going to charge you $35 this year. There's some guy in your area that's trying to undercut me and I don't want to lose your business.
He does good work and I told him so. He offered me the $35 rate just the same. Go figure.
For $35 he's willing to drive to my house, test my sprinkler system, and send in the paperwork for me. If there's ever a problem, he'll retest it for free. Not just anyone can do the work either. You need to be a certified backflow tester.
The theory that you could greatly reduce your risk by diversifying outside the United States isn't holding up that well in hindsight.
Avoiding Japan starting in 1991 wouldn't have even helped much, had you known to do it. Unfortunately, that's not exactly what investors were told to do.
"The world has seriously mistaken what has happened in Japan," said Richard Koo, a senior economist at the Nomura Research Institute. "The Bank of Japan is trying to slow the economy with every tool they have. This is a policy-led slowdown because it's the only way they can clear out all the excesses of the past few years, when monetary policy was too easy."
Added Susumu Kato, chief economist for Goldman, Sachs (Japan): "There are problems, but they're manageable. We don't see those kind of crash scenarios taking place."
"I can't in any way subscribe to a China crash scenario – even in real estate," says Jonathan Auerbach, managing director at the institutional brokerage Auerbach Grayson. "There's a sort of knee-jerk reaction when copper is down 10% in the last three days. But it got hammered along with all the other base metals, and that doesn't mean that China is going to stop buying it."
Now, there are no takers for the base metals in the market. China, India and other buyers have reduced imports for these metals and the inventories are piling up at several ports across the globe.
The result is simple. A crash in prices. Already within corrective environments, the stock panic has bled the base metals to dangerously unhealthy levels. Copper, zinc, nickel, lead, and aluminum have seen declines of 69%, 77%, 84%, 78%, and 61% respectively from their recent highs.
Is it even remotely possible that Auerbach Grayson could be somewhat biased in their analysis?
Auerbach Grayson & Co (abbr: AGCO) is a New York-based stockbroker that deals predominantly in the equity of non-US based companies, catering to institutional investors.
Here's a chart showing copper's annual price from 1913 to 2008 (adjusted for inflation).
As of today, copper trades at $3.13 per pound. It now sits at pre-crash levels. I remain deflationary.
1. Why is positive feedback important? The key feature of positive feedback is that small disturbances are amplified. When positive feedback is present, there is some causal loop where a small change creates an effect that causes an even bigger change -- like a ball rolling down an increasingly steep hill.
2. Systemic risk is the risk that an amplification or leverage or positive feedback process is built into a system, this is usually unknown, and under certain conditions this process can amplify exponentially and rapidly lead to destructive or chaotic behavior. A Ponzi scheme is a good example of a positive-feedback system, because its output (profit) is fed back to the input (new investors), causing rapid growth toward collapse.
3. In sociology, a self-fulfilling prophecy is a positive feedback loop between beliefs and behavior: if enough people believe that something is true, their behavior makes it true, and observations of their behavior in turn increase belief. A classic example is a bank run.
I found it hard to believe that one trader could cause such carnage by simply typing a "b" instead of an "m".
I did not find it hard to believe that several competing computer algorithms might indirectly explore each other's black boxes and find neither willing to support prices. If that was indeed the case, then these competing computer algorithms would simultaneously come up with the same conclusion. Sell!
In science and engineering, a black box is a device, system or object which can (and sometimes can only) be viewed solely in terms of its input, output and transfer characteristics without any knowledge of its internal workings. Almost anything might be referred to as a black box: a transistor, an algorithm, or the human mind.
That is exactly how program trading works. What goes on within each firm's algorithms is a closely guarded secret.
One firm can't know what the black boxes of other firms are doing except by watching them. Watch a black box long enough and you'll start to figure out how they will probably react to changing inputs though.
Let's say there are two firms and two black boxes. We'll call them BlackboxA and BlackboxB. In the early days BlackboxA and BlackboxB were simple algorithms. They didn't know or care about each other's existence.
Some bright guy at Firm A decided that his black box could be smarter if it started watching BlackboxB. If BlackboxA knew BlackboxB would sell, then BlackboxA would sell first. This made BlackboxA smarter.
Meanwhile...
Some bright guy at Firm B decided that his black box could be smarter if it started watching BlackboxA. If BlackboxB knew BlackboxA would sell, then BlackboxB would sell first. This made BlackboxB smarter.
See the problem here? BlackboxA relies on information from BlackboxB. BlackboxB relies on information from BlackboxA. BlackboxA therefore indirectly relies on information from BlackboxA. It's a form of circular logic. That's bad.
Circular references can appear in computer programming when one piece of code requires the result from another, but that code needs the result from the first.
The entire set of functions is now worthless because none of them can return any useful information whatsoever.
A circular reference represents a big problem in computing.
Picture two cells (A1 and B1) in Excel each representing one of the black boxes above. You can type "=B1-1" into cell A1 in Excel. A1 now relies on the information from B1. There will be no complaints. Once you type "=A1-1" into cell B1 there's a big problem though. It makes no sense. Excel now has no way to determine what the value of either cell should be.
Microsoft cannot calculate a formula. Cell references in the formula refer to the formula's result, creating a circular reference.
You can still do it in Excel though if you turn on the maximum number of iterations feature. It will be amusing if you do. Every time the spreadsheet recalculates, the value of those two cells will get smaller (as each cell tries to be smaller than its neighbor).
Market sources say the confluence of events likely triggered electronic selling programs. As that selling commenced, the human element of the markets quickly evaporated and computerized trading programs wantonly sold stocks at whatever price was available, creating a feeding frenzy.
That seems to make the most sense to me. It's just an opinion though.
Absent from the list is the only one that matters.
Your money is now worth more.
Now you know why I love investing in boring blue-chip stocks. The duller, the better.
Was there a powerful rally in boring blue-chip stocks today that I somehow missed?
Not only are many of them priced pretty reasonably right now: They let you sleep better, too.
Sleep better? Seriously? I'm fairly sure that even a quad shot of espresso would be a more effective sedative.
Be honest: When you heard about the Dow or saw the footage from Athens, your thoughts immediately went to that exciting new "aggressive" fund your broker just sold you.
I can say with 100% honesty that my first thoughts did not go to that exciting "aggressive" fund my broker just sold me. I merely sighed. I figured even more money would flood into my TIPS and it would be even harder to safely make money off of money in the future. My thoughts then turned to what might happen next if this continued. At some point money would flow back out of TIPS as deflationary fears rose. It wouldn't be the first time.
Did you really worry about your Kellogg stock?
I would have worried about Kellogg stock had I owned it. The last time stocks crashed in a major way Kellogg fell right along with them. On September 26, 2008 Kellogg stock closed at $57.39. On March 11, 2009 Kellogg closed at $35.84. That's a 38% loss. Believe it or not, that is the kind of thing I tend to worry about. Call it a crazy "falling tide sinks all ships" sort of mindset.
At today's 0.1% interest rate on three month T-Bills, a loss of that magnitude would take roughly five centuries to earn back safely even if one ignored inflation. I just don't have that kind of time on my side.
Let's say we had a time machine that could transport us back to December 12, 2007 and get some advice from this very same author. What might he have said then to comfort us during that plunge?
The latest move from the central banks, which is aimed at addressing that specific issue, is probably more important than the interest rate cuts. The market's reaction to the two events – a plunge after yesterday's rate cut followed by a rally in response to the liquidity plan – certainly supports that.
So how should an investor react?
Make your own call – but at least look at the big banking stocks.
Citigroup closed at $31.47 that day.
The charts certainly tell a story. It's hard to avoid the conclusion that the banks are either going to hell in a handcart, or they are going dirt cheap.
Using hindsight we can now determine thewinner. As can be seen in the link, the readers of this blog were generally not surprised by the sudden appearance of a handcart in a sea of fiery magma.
Citigroup closed today at $4.04. That's an 87% loss from its bargain levels.
As you can see, our growth has been a bit lower lately but that's sure to pick back up at some point. We could pretty much count on 10% returns historically, but hey, at least we're getting something. Right?
You know what? I'm just not that happy with the chart though. It seems a bit vague. I think I should probably label a bit more of it and supply just a bit more data.
Let's try again.
Click to enlarge.
Oh yes. That's much better. It's even starting to look a bit like our stock market once inflation, our exponentially rising national debt, and irrational exuberances are factored in.
I went through the holdings of TIP line by line today.
I took each bond in the fund (as of May 4th) and used the treasury daily yield curve to determine its approximate real yield. I interpolated the yields using this data as seen on the Treasury's website (as seen in my table below).
0 years: 0.00% (just an estimate, since it is not provided) 5 years: 0.34% 7 years: 0.82% 10 years: 1.25% 20 years: 1.61% 30 years: 1.73%
Here's a simple example. If a bond was due to mature in 6 years, then I used the average of 0.34% and 0.82% to come up with 0.58%.
Once I had estimates of the real yield of each bond in the fund, I then weighted each of them based on the amount of that bond in the fund.
My best guess for TIP's current real yield (the yield after inflation) is 0.82%. There's some room for error there but it is probably fairly close. The fund charges expenses of 0.2% so let's subtract that off. It leaves us with a real yield of 0.62%.
There is certainly risk in TIP at these prices and I would argue that the upside is very limited.
That said, I continue to hold it in my IRA. It's not like real yields are good anywhere these days. I'm simply trying to urge some caution here. Don't expect more from TIP than it can deliver.
If inflation averages the 2.16% over the next 10 years that the bond market expects (seen by subtracting the 10 Year TIPS yield of 1.25% from the 10 Year nominal treasury yield of 3.41%) and nothing else changes, then this fund should provide an ongoing 2.78% return. That's it.
Correction: I said that real yields were "after inflation". I meant to say that real yields are the yields "over inflation". For example... If you earn a 0.5% real yield when inflation is 2%, then you earn 2.5% overall.