Wednesday, March 31, 2010

Candy Bars, the BLS, and Shadowstats

Have you ever wondered why the CPI, GDP and employment numbers run counter to your personal and business experiences? The problem lies in biased and often manipulated government reporting. - John Williams, Shadow Government Statistics

I have not. I track every penny I spend and have been doing so since 2000. I'm just not seeing the inflation that Shadowstats claims.

Let's try a simple test using the historical price of Hershey's candy bars. If the CPI was vastly under-reporting inflation over the years, then surely the price of candy bars must be rising at a rate far higher than the government will admit. Therefore, all we have to do is look at the long-term trend in inflation adjusted candy bar prices.

I should also point out that
Sugar #11 has been in a bull market. If inflation was going to strike anywhere, surely sugar-packed candy bars would be among the first to feel the inflationary pain. Therefore, it is probably not fair to judge the BLS on candy bar prices alone. Let's try anyway though.



The long-term trend is flat. The CPI has clearly been tracking the long-term price of candy bars fairly well. The two data points I offer from 2009 are well within the margin of error. You will note that inflation adjusted terms, the most recent Safeway data point is very similar to the pricing of candy bars seen in the 1970s (the last time energy prices were high).

I do not see any signs of a CPI conspiracy based on the price of candy bars.


Why do people continue to give credibility to an operation like Shadowstats? Now that's something that I'd like to hear explained. - James Hamilton, Professor of Economics at the University of California, San Diego

I'd really like to know too. Perhaps people just love a good conspiracy theory. Here's a favorite of mine.

Top 10 Wackiest Conspiracy Theories

Esoteric Hitlerists and conspiracy theorists interested in Nazi mysticism and World War II have speculated that the Germans landed on the Moon as early as 1942.

According to other theories it is believed that the Nazis had made contact with 'half a dozen' alien races, including the malevolent Reptilians.


Source Data:
The Food Timeline
BLS: Historical CPI

Oil at $83? Earning 1% Interest? Things Not to Hoard!

Best Stuff Not to Buy in Bulk

Candy

One consumer put it best on Savingadvice.com: "If I go to my local store and but 2 candy bars for $1 a piece, I spend $2 and they will last a week. I buy a box at Costco of 24 candy bars for $12, they still will be gone in a week. Even though the unit price is less, I end up spending more."

We buy candy bars in bulk to save money. Believe it or not, we do not actually eat 12 times more candy bars per week just because they are in the house. I know it is hard to believe, but it is true. We apparently have some self-control.

I should also mention that it does not actually cause you to spend more money on food. You can easily spend just $4 per day on food if candy bars are all that you eat. A Snickers Bar has 280 calories of food in it. That said, you should probably plan on getting scurvy at some point though.

Paper Towels

It may sound like a good idea at first. Paper towels are not perishable and they do tend to cost less when you buy them in bulk.

They do tend to cost less when bought in bulk and they are not perishable. Don't stock up on them though, especially with oil sitting at $83 per barrel. Keep the money in your savings account earning 1% interest instead.

Toilet Paper

Just like with paper towels, you don't want to go overboard purchasing toilet paper.

Good grief. It must be a slow news day. It's a great day for sarcasm though.

Monday, March 29, 2010

Pleasure and Pain



The gray areas represent recessions.

As seen in the chart, oil has gone up faster than the S&P 500 this decade. Oil has also gone up faster than the S&P 500 during this economic recovery.

Should this new long-term trend continue, I would expect more pain than pleasure. Note that the trend can continue even if oil's price does not rise. Stocks falling in price would be sufficient.


Hussman Funds - Weekly Market Commentary

As I emphasized last week, even if we had no concern at all about a second wave of credit strains, we would still be fully hedged here based on the present combination of rich valuations, overbought conditions, overbullish sentiment, and hostile yield pressures. Presently, we are also at the peak of concern about the potential for fresh credit difficulties to emerge, as we move into the first portion of the Alt-A / Option ARM reset schedule.

Econbrowser: Not a textbook rebound

Is this as good as it gets? For the time being at least, it seems to be.

See Also:
Trend Line Disclaimer

Source Data:
EIA: Crude Oil Spot Prices
Yahoo: Historical Prices for S&P 500
NBER: Business Cycle Expansions and Contractions

Congress FAIL

Coverage Now for Sick Children? Check Fine Print

The new law says that health plans and insurers offering individual or group coverage “may not impose any pre-existing condition exclusion with respect to such plan or coverage” for children under 19, starting in “plan years” that begin on or after Sept. 23, 2010.

But, insurers say, until 2014, the law does not require them to write insurance at all for the child or the family. In the language of insurance, the law does not include a “guaranteed issue” requirement before then.

Consumer advocates worry that instead of refusing to cover treatment for a specific pre-existing condition, an insurer might simply deny coverage for the child or the family.

Saturday, March 27, 2010

Lehman's Brother?



Leeroy Jenkins (video)

Leeroy's actions have caused the larger World of Warcraft community to use his name to represent any action that could be seen as potentially dangerous and/or incredibly stupid. The Leeroy movie is generally suggested to be a must-see for any and all WoW players. It has become a popular term for a person who causes a bad pull that causes a group wipe.

Lehman Brothers

Immediately following the bankruptcy filing, an already distressed financial market began a period of extreme volatility, during which the Dow experienced its largest one day point loss, largest intra-day range (more than 1,000 points) and largest daily point gain. What followed was what many have called the “perfect storm” of economic distress factors and eventually a $700bn bailout package (Troubled Asset Relief Program) prepared by Henry Paulson, Secretary of the Treasury, and approved by Congress.

Friday, March 26, 2010

Silly Roth IRA Math

Roth IRA Conversion Will Never Look Better

He was especially surprised at the large percentage of people who think their tax rate will decline when they retire.

Um, probably because they no longer have a job bringing in steady income? Hello? Anyone in there?

Many investment sites have Roth conversion calculators. The results are only as good as the assumptions you use. I ran some scenarios on this Morningstar calculator, using conservative assumptions. I used a $100,000 IRA balance for conversion and assumed that none of this balance had been funded with post-tax money. I also assumed annual returns of 5 percent now and in retirement (many calculators use higher returns as a default),and said that I would retire at the age of 70 and that my retirement would last 20 years. Tax rates are important, too. I used a current income tax rate of 28 percent and a 15 percent rate for long-term capital gains. Again, to be conservative, I said my tax rate at retirement would rise to 33 percent.

Using these assumptions, I entered various ages as of the end of 2010 and produced these comparisons:

At age 60 in 2010, converting to a Roth would cost $28,000 in 2010 taxes and provide post-tax income of $13,070 a year in retirement, compared with $11,681 for a traditional IRA.


A 33% tax rate at retirement with a post-tax income of just $13,070 a year? You have got to be joking!

To put this in perspective, I earned $33,915 in 2009 (deflation hit my inflation protected treasuries). I owed $1,994 in taxes. My post-tax income was therefore $31,921 and my retirement tax rate was therefore 6%. That is a far lower tax rate than when I was working. So why would I have wanted to prepay taxes at 28% when I was ultimately taxed at just 6%?

Now try to imagine what my tax rate at retirement would be if I had a post-tax income of just $13,070 instead of $31,921. Hint: The 2009 Federal Poverty level is
$10,830.

In his defense, he did say that "the results are only as good as the assumptions you use" though. Unfortunately, if you start off ASSUMING that your tax rate will be higher in retirement than it was when you were being paid to work then it isn't all that hard to show that a Roth IRA is good for you. Garbage in, garbage out!

Update:


Gravestone Generator

Thursday, March 25, 2010

Stimulus Physics Update #1

In February, I joked that the stock market might be using cartoon physics to propel itself higher. Here is the chart that I offered.



This is where we are now.



Damn it! It seems I forgot to factor in "hot air" friction! The trajectory is clearly coming up a bit short of the original estimate.

Once again, please don't read too much into this. Almost anything can happen in a world filled with cartoon stimulus and/or cartoon physics. I'm certainly not going to short the stock market based on these silly charts. I'm more than happy just watching from the sidelines.

The vast majority of the time the stock market does not use or need cartoon physics to function properly. It might be different this time though. Who knows? Further, it would be preposterous to argue that the stock market could ever come down. Everyone knows that it only goes up, again.

Speaking of cartoon physics, is
Capital One Financial possibly rolling over again or is it just me? I was never given the gift of technical analysis. I can never see into the future. It might seem like it at times, but that's probably just my gut talking. It is currently ready to rumble.

See Also:
Stimulus Physics
Trend Line Disclaimer

Source Data:
Yahoo: Historical Prices for Dow Jones Industrial Average

A New York Restaurant Is Prepared for Inflation Volatility

New York bar to set menu prices like stocks

NEW YORK (Reuters) - What's the value of a pint of beer? Let the market decide, says a new restaurant in Manhattan where prices for food and beverages will fluctuate like stock prices in increments according to demand.

Note that this system will work great during severe deflation, stagflation, and severe hyperinflation.

Owners Levent Cakar and Damon Bae admit the stock exchange theme is a gimmick but hope a good deal on drinks and their hamburger's tastiness will win over customers.

It is a very amusing gimmick.

New York has about 23,000 restaurants, with about 4,400 opening each year according to the city's Department of Health, which tracks establishment licenses.

If 4,400 open each year but there are only 23,000 total, you can pretty much do the math to see how hard it is to open a successful restaurant. Here's some help with the math. It would only take 5.2 years for 23,000 restaurants to be created at a 4,400 per year pace. New York became a state 222 years ago though.

The restaurant opens April 1.

They are opening it on April Fool's Day. They might succeed. It tells me that they at least have a sense of humor. If they do succeed I suspect that a restaurant currently near them might no longer succeed, especially in this economy. Behold the power of capitalism.